Daniel Toy subsequently moved to the Christian Kingseed blacksmith shop at the corner of North Street and Ohio Avenue for a business venture with him, and after that, he enjoyed business relationships with Ben Slusser, members of the Haslup family, and Philip Smith.

In "Memoirs of the Miami Valley", Judge Barnes relates an amusing incident involving Mr. Toy. He was a man "of extraordinary size and strength" given, "in the manner of the times, to wrestling." A wrestling bout with his partner, David Edgar, was described as follows: "The contestants wrestled themselves off the Court Street bridge and into the canal, where the town marshall, to preserve his dignity in the face of a crowd of onlookers, placed both men under arrest for quarreling. (After the bout they) delivered their dripping persons to the strong hand of the law, were marched to the court and fined, each paying the other's penalty, and shaking hands, to the marshall's discomfiture."