Traveling Through Time With the Shelby County Historical Society
Feature Article on Carry Nation. Topic: WOMEN & PEOPLE
Written by Jim Sayre in February, 1997

TEMPERANCE MOVEMENT HAD ROOTS IN SHELBY COUNTY, OHIO...Pg 2

Carry Nation’s free-swinging assaults on saloons came nearly 20 years after a widespread movement against liquor interests by Victorian ladies using tactics akin to those of Ghandi and Martin Luther King in the next century: nonviolence. In 1873, groups of church women in Ohio towns including Hillsboro, Washington Court House, Cincinnati, Columbus, and Cleveland staged marches and prayers-in at local drinking holes, establishing their tactic of embarrassing saloon keepers and their patrons. "The ladies’ success was due in part to the deference most men still showed ‘women of quality’ in the Victorian Era" (Ohio and Its People, by Knepper). Such demonstrations caused a temporary suspension of liquor traffic, but local laws against obstructing the streets soon curbed the ladies and the flurry of anti-saloon activities subsided within a year.

Nation’s later "hatchetations" would become an embarrassment, not to saloon keepers who were more often just plain angry, but to the "women of quality" who would sing hymns and pray outside saloons, but abhor the unlady like violence that became Nation’s trademark. Area towns were not exempt from the "grand crusade." Following a few weeks of demonstrations in Shelby County, the Sidney Journal reported ..."The saloons at Newport (maybe one once operated by Gloyd) have quit selling whisky by the drink..." (SJ, Apr. 3, 1874).

Snow was falling on Piqua’s streets in late January 1874 as two hundred women, after meeting at the First Presbyterian Church, marched on the city’s saloons reading the word, singing, and entreating the owners to close their evil establishments (Women and Temperance, Piqua, Ohio, by Oda). The bartender at the City Hotel confronted the women by declaring "I must take a bath" and then began removing his clothing. Buckets of cleaning water thrown in their direction were among the indignities visited upon the crusaders.

The active street work of the women. Crusaders gradually came to an end as fewer women were willing to brave the scorn of the saloonkeepers for such inconclusive and often very temporary results...Many of the women turned to the...local chapter of the Women’s Christian Temperance Union" organized in mid-February, according to Oda. Piqua had supported three breweries and nineteen saloons in 1870, but the saloons closed after Piqua’s prohibition ordinance went into effect several years later (Oda; SJ, Apr. 3, 1874).

Temperance lectures at the Methodist Church in February 1874 and organization of a "Woman’s Whisky War" soon after at the Presbyterian Church marked the beginning of Sidney’s temperance movement. "The ladies of Sidney are thoroughly organized, equipped, and disciplined, and have a large squad of men in the rear to support them with their counsel, money, and even assistance if necessary," the local paper reported (SJ, Feb. 13, 1874). "Mrs. Wykes was elected President, Mrs. Thomas Stephenson, Vice President, and Miss Ella Rogers, Secretary."

[ Back ]  [ Next ]  [ Up ]  [ New Search ]