| Local genealogists can find no name record
other than simply "Charles Starrett,"
although the known facts of Charles Starretts life are meager. In fact, executors of
the will of Mr. Starretts father wrote him off as a beneficiary, noting that he
probably died in Kentucky. No, he died In Ohio and was buried in Sidney...at least twice. First
laid to rest in the old Presbyterian Cemetery, his body was removed when the high school,
now Bridgeview, was built in 1912, according to the late Shelby County historian Paul
Sherman. But was Starrett first buried in the old Starrett cemetery, now the triangular Schultz Battery Memorial park at
the divergence of South Main and South Ohio streets? This is the claim of a Starrett
researcher of the same name but different branch of the family, Bill Starrett of
Indianapolis and formerly of Sidney. But, for sure, Charles Starrett now lies beneath a
Graceland Cemetery memorial of dimensions befitting a towns father.
Local historians believe that a sharp investor like Starrett would have specified his
name in the Sidney land agreement if indeed his middle name had been Sidney and had
he wanted the town named for him. In short, he covered all the angles. But, there is no
such clause.
Starretts land was chosen for Sidney in 1819 after a short trial seat of justice
at Hardin, mainly because the Great
Miami River site was more centrally located in the county. And, Mr. Starrett was ready to
deal. He offered his land for the town, but he made sure that the county seat would
permanently remain there and he wanted half the proceeds from the sale of lots.
Agreement came quickly and 113 lots were laid out in the original plat. |

This is a map of the
downtown portion of Charles Starretts donation. It is the original town plot [Note:
Lots #105-113 are not shown on this drawing].
[ Back ] [ Next ]
[ Up ] [ New Search
] |