Sixty thousand tickets were printed with a
ticket price of the tidy sum of one dollar each. Despite their best efforts, only 38,145
tickets were sold. The Thompson family won the lottery and claimed Carey's Hall. The net profit from the venture was
just $9,154, and Shelby County's effort to honor its soldiers had not gotten off to a very
good start. Four years of inactivity then followed. Within three weeks after the Ohio
General Assembly passed an act in May, 1871, that provided for the appointment of trustees
and the raising of moneys to build monuments to honor the soldiers of the "War of the
Rebellion," local attorney Willis P. Stowell presented a petition of the Shelby
County Common Pleas Court, resulting in the appointment of the first trustees.
The idea for the creation of a building, rather than a monument, to honor the soldiers
was discussed generally in town, but the details were first raised in an anonymous Sidney
Journal Letter to the Editor, printed in its June 17, 1870, edition. The
author commented:
"The only question then, it seems to me, should be, what kind of structure will
best answer the purpose. While we desire to commemorate the dead and honor the living
soldier, ought we not to consult common prudence as to the best method of effecting this
object? The useful as well as the ornamental ought to be studied. A building would meet
this condition better than a marble shaft."
The author went on to suggest most of the basic ideas, including the concept of a
cultural center, that were later incorporated in the structure. After much public debate,
it was decided to purchase the lot that was the site of the Ackerly Tavern, and before
that, the old Farmer's Hotel.